The pizzas here are huge and heavily red-sauced. The crust is pretty close to what you’d find in New York (we like to order ours well-done), and the white pizza with globs of ricotta is delicious. Bring some hungry people with you, though - they don’t sell slices.
More spots in Capitol HillSee more
The Other Coast Cafe
Other Coast Cafe is a mini sandwich chain for hot and cold baguette sandwiches. This one’s in Capitol Hill.
Redhook Brewlab is a taproom in Capitol Hill with American bar food and wood-fired pizzas.
Big Mario’s Pizza
Big Mario’s is a very respectable NY-style slice joint in Cap Hill during the day, and a late night eats mecca at night.
More Italian spotsSee more
Tavolàta is the Italian spot in Belltown perfect for eating homemade pastas and cured meats with a date or friends.
Bisato is an outstanding upscale Italian restaurant in Pioneer Square where the a la carte options are way better than the tasting menu.
Suggested by our writers
Supreme is a West Seattle pizzeria with New York-style pies and slices, plus boozy slushies and excellent garlic knots.
Frēlard Pizza Company
Want to have an adult pizza party? With beer? On a patio? Frēlard in Fremont is your move.
Dino’s Tomato Pie
Dino’s is one of few places in Seattle that knows how to do New York pizza. It’s one of our favorite spots in Cap Hill for dinner and drinks.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more