Located in an old hardware store in South Philly, Mr. Martino’s Trattoria is exactly the kind of old-school Italian BYOB that tourists expect to see as soon as they step out of 30th Street Station. And it checks all the boxes: homemade pastas cooked in a one-woman kitchen, furniture and decor that were probably there when they moved in, and a staff that acts like you’re part of their obscenely large family (for better or worse). The one problem is that it’s only open on weekends, so you have to either get there early or call on a day that they happen to be picking up the phone for a reservation.
More spots in East PassyunkSee more
Anastasi Seafood is an old-school spot in the Italian Market where they’ll cook any fish however you want it.
Ristorante Pesto is an Italian BYOB in East Passyunk where you should start a night out with a lot of pasta.
More Italian spotsSee more
Voltaco’s is a take-out-only Italian spot in Ocean City where you’ll find some of the best hoagies and chicken parm around.
Chef Vola’s is an old-school Italian spot in Atlantic City that’s straight out of Boardwalk Empire.
Talula’s is a pizza place in Asbury Park with some of the best baked goods and Neopolitan pies down the shore.
Suggested by our writers
Vetri is expensive, completely over the top, and possibly the best restaurant in Philadelphia.
Vernick Food & Drink
Vernick is one of the best restaurants in Philly, with a formal dining room upstairs and a more casual bar below.
Murph’s is an Irish pub in Fishtown that also happens to make some of our favorite Italian food in the city.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more