This terrific slice spot is counter-service-only, but happens to specialize in crunchy-edged square pies you’ll want to share with friends over a few drinks. Happily, there’s a workaround. Their sister spot Lucille’s, a plant-filled coffee and cocktail bar with a solid all-day menu, is located just two doors down. And they really don’t mind if you bring your pizza over. Order the broccoli rabe and sweet sausage or the pepperoni cup-packed grandma square pie to-go, then head down the block for martinis, rum punch, and craft beers. And if for some reason you aren’t in the mood for pizza, the kale caesar salad and baby back ribs on Lucille’s dinner menu are both good choices.
More spots in HarlemSee more
More Italian spotsSee more
Il Gattopardo is an Italian restaurant in Midtown that feels like a very expensive living room and makes good pasta.
Gersi is a casual, cash-only Italian place in Carroll Gardens where you can bring a date, get some red-sauce pasta, and maybe even sit outside.
Pizza Moto is a solid Neapolitan-style neighborhood pizza place in Red Hook, and, if you live in the area, you should eat here often.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more