Known for specialties by the slice, the ideal way to enjoy Crust is to eat whatever slices are available while you wait for a full pie to bring home - I like to think of this as maximum pizza efficiency. If there’s a Buffalo pie ready to go, I will immediately forget everything I'm doing and dive into a slice (or three) topped with the most delicious homemade Buffalo sauce I’ve ever had. As a sauce queen, I can’t recommend the Pollock enough - an absolute stunner of a pie splashed with both vodka sauce and pesto. It’s not often available by the slice, but this is the pie worth waiting for. Ya know, while you eat your other slice(s).
Where we've featured it
More spots in Staten IslandSee more
Jelisa’s Cafe is a Dominican bakery on Staten Island where you can stop by for a big plate of pernil or a smoothie.
The Phunky Elephant
The Phunky Elephant on Staten Island is a tavern with American food, bingo brunch, and a big outdoor area where you can hang out with a friend.
More Pizza spotsSee more
Austin Street Pizza
Austin Street Pizza makes crunchy, thick square slices you should try if you’re in Forest Hills.
Ribalta is big Italian spot near Union Square that serves solid Neapolitan-style pizzas and works for fun group dinners.
Artistic Pizza in Greenwich Village serves a variety of vegan and non-vegan slices you should definitely take to Washington Square Park.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more