Wave Image
Don’t see your city? Drop us a line and let us know where you’d like us to go next.

Send Us Feedback

Thank You

We’re always looking to make The Infatuation the best platform to find restaurants, and we appreciate your feedback!
NYC

Guide

Where To Eat & Drink In East Harlem

Whether you just moved in, want to explore it for the first time, or are a neighborhood veteran, here are the East Harlem restaurants to know.

DK
Written by
Danielle Krinsky
9 Spots
Launch Map
9 Spots
Launch Map

Sure – to some people, East Harlem may be the place you go to buy oversized rolls of Bounty at Costco. But tons of people live here, there are lots of great bars and restaurants, and ultimately it’s probably only a matter of time before East Harlem becomes the new Williamsburg. So whether you just moved to the area, want to explore it for the first time and don’t know where to start, or are a neighborhood veteran, here’s our guide to all the East Harlem spots that should be on your radar.

The Spots

1

The Guthrie Inn

$$$$ 1259 Park Ave

This cocktail bar is the type of place you’ll want to roll up your sleeves and stay awhile. The leather couches and candlelit room make it feel like you’re hanging out in a friend’s living room. They don’t serve food, but the cocktails and playlists are good enough you’ll hardly remember that you’re hungry. But when you do, Earl’s next door has you covered.

2

No longer the size of a dorm room, Earl’s has recently undergone renovations and expanded. The deer wall mural make you feel like you have been teleported to a cabin in the woods, and the mac and cheese will just make you generally happy. Don’t miss the Earl’s taco, which is a fried scallion pancake shell filled with pork. Wash it all down with one of their craft beers on tap and enjoy a well-deserved food coma. You earned it. If you grab a seat at the communal table, you’ll have direct view of their TV which plays all the Sunday games.

3

Lupita's Restaurant

$$$$ 2049 2nd Ave

It’s nothing fancy and you definitely won’t need a reservation, but that’s okay – you’re going to Lupita’s for its excellent Mexican food. Our favorites include the vegetarian enchiladas, pollo flautas, and the bistec sopes.

4

Lexington Pizza Parlour

$$$$ 1590 Lexington Ave

Despite the name, Lexington Pizza Parlour has a lot more than just pizza. This neighborhood restaurant has a homey feel, thanks to both the jazz playing in the background and the extremely friendly staff. Order the Luna Piena, which is a half Margherita pizza with smoked mozzarella and half ricotta calzone rolled into half of the pizza pie. Yes, this is a thing that exists. If you’re still hungry, go for the chicken parm or any of their homemade pastas.

5

A true classic. The East Harlem location of Patsy’s Pizzeria is the original, and has been in this very same location since 1933 when Pasquale ‘Patsy’ himself opened the doors. You don’t need to get too creative here with toppings. Order the plain pie – it’s the reason you’re coming to Patsy’s.

6

El Paso Restaurante Mexicano

$$$$ 1643 Lexington Ave

There are three steps to success at El Paso: Grab a seat at the bar, get yourself a margarita or anything from the extensive tequila menu, and order the chips (served warm) and guacamole, which is extremely fresh. The shortrib tacos are a big standout, and their garden patio (which kind of resembles a tree house) makes for great outdoor seating in the warmer months.

7

Mountain Bird

$$$$
$$$$ 251 East 110th St.

A poultry-focused French bistro run by a Japanese couple (the husband is the chef while his wife runs the front of house). Mountain Bird gets its name because the menu is all things poultry served in non-traditional ways – like the bite sized head-to-toe sampler which includes chicken heart and liver mousse. The food is excellent and different from what you’ll see on every other menu.

8

The Lexington Social

$$$$ 1634 Lexington Ave

Lexington Social has Super Cute Reasonably Priced Restaurant To Catch Up With A Few Friends written all over it: It’s an intimate wine bar, so you’ll be able to hear one another speak while sharing tasty Mediterranean small plates. The malfatis (dumplings filled with spinach and ricotta) and the shaved brussel sprouts are among our favorites. Don’t sleep on their happy hour either: $4 beers and $6 wines.

9

Taco Mix

$$$$ 234 E 116th St

This tiny shack serves what are very possibly the best al pastor tacos in all of New York City. These alone are worth a trip to East Harlem – and since Taco Mix is open 21.5 hours a day (9am – 5:30am), you have lots of opportunities to make the pilgrimage.

You'll need a better browser for that!
Upgrade to Chrome and start finding Restaurants.